Subscribe to become a member of the

Sweet Treat Society!

For the most passionate toffee fans, there's the Goodytwos Toffee of the Month Club.

Members receive Goody-licious toffee delivered monthly to their doorsteps for just $49.95/month with FREE shipping. Enjoy traditional favorites AND seasonal flavors (including an exclusive flavor only available to members)!

SUBSCRIBE

January Goody Box

  • Traditional Toffee— Rich, buttery goodness with Madagascar Bourbon vanilla, 72% dark cacao and Belgian milk chocolate, all kissed with almonds
  • Sweet & Salty Toffee — Sweet fresh almonds, Madagascar Bourbon vanilla and 72% dark Belgian cacao chocolate, all smooched with French coarse sea salt
  • Cookies & Cream Toffee — The ULTIMATE dessert combo is now in a toffee square! Fresh creamery butter, pure cane sugar, and decadent macadamia nuts coated in luscious white chocolate then topped with your favorite cream filled cookie... say no more, I'll take 10!
  • Milk Caramel Rum Toffee — We take the traditional English toffee ingredients of creamery butter, pure cane sugar, Madagascar vanilla, and Belgian milk chocolate, stir in some fresh cashews, then add dark rum…YUM!

February Goody Box

  • Traditional Toffee — Rich, buttery goodness with Madagascar Bourbon vanilla, 72% dark cacao and Belgian milk chocolate, all kissed with almonds
  • Double Crossed Toffee — Fresh creamery butter, pure cane sugar, sweet almonds, smooth Madagascar vanilla, decadent milk and dark chocolate all criss-crossed with white chocolate
  • Nutty Berry Toffee — With an extra dash of vitamin L-O-V-E, we have combined creamery butter, pure cane sugar, fresh pecans, and 100% real strawberries all covered in smooth Belgian chocolate. The front side is creamy strawberry white chocolate with Valentine's sprinkles. The back side is coated with 72% dark cacao and chopped pecans. This is a duo you don't want to miss!
  • Goodypolitan Belgian Chocolate — When Neapolitan meets Goodytwos! This delightful treat features layers of Belgian dark, white, and strawberry white chocolate. No square is complete without a sprinkling of mini dark chocolate chips!

March Goody Box

  • Traditional Toffee — Rich, buttery goodness with Madagascar Bourbon vanilla, 72% dark cacao and Belgian milk chocolate, all kissed with almonds
  • Double Crossed Toffee — Fresh creamery butter, pure cane sugar, sweet almonds, smooth Madagascar vanilla, decadent milk and dark chocolate all criss-crossed with white chocolate
  • Goody Luck Toffee — With this deliciously dark toffee, you too can experience the "Goody Luck" of the Irish! Fresh almonds, sweet sugar, creamery butter, and Guinness stout all coated with pure dark chocolate and pistachios. Are you feeling lucky?
  • Crème de la Crunch Toffee — Fresh creamery butter, pure cane sugar, fresh pecans and almonds, and velvety coffee liqueur all covered in Belgian white chocolate and sprinkled with pecans. Ooh, la la!

April Goody Box

  • Traditional Toffee — Rich, buttery goodness with Madagascar Bourbon vanilla, 72% dark cacao and Belgian milk chocolate, all kissed with almonds
  • Sweet & Salty Toffee — Sweet fresh almonds, Madagascar Bourbon vanilla and 72% dark Belgian cacao chocolate, all smooched with French coarse sea salt
  • Coconut Macaroon Toffee — In this batch of toffee, we’ve added a different type of nut…or should I say coconut! Belgian white chocolate and dark chocolate smothered coconut toffee all sprinkled with more freshly toasted coconut. Did I say it has coconut?
  • Double Trouble Toffee — Temptation times Two! Spanish peanuts, fresh creamery butter, Madagascar vanilla and smooth Belgian milk chocolate. Then we sprinkle crunchy roasted, salted peanuts to top it off. Sold!

May Goody Box

  • Traditional Toffee — Rich, buttery goodness with Madagascar Bourbon vanilla, 72% dark cacao and Belgian milk chocolate, all kissed with almonds
  • Sweet & Salty Toffee — Sweet fresh almonds, Madagascar Bourbon vanilla and 72% dark Belgian cacao chocolate, all smooched with French coarse sea salt
  • Fleur Two Lis Toffee — Our handcrafted toffee, with a bit of Ooh la la Lavender! Made with fresh creamery butter, pure cane sugar, white and Belgian milk chocolate… Do you love it? Oui!
  • Milk & Honey Toffee — Bringing the sweetness of Roark Acres honey to Goodytwos! Fresh peanut toffee infused with Roark Acres honey coated in creamy milk chocolate then sprinkled with golden sugar crystals.

June Goody Box

  • Traditional Toffee — Rich, buttery goodness with Madagascar Bourbon vanilla, 72% dark cacao and Belgian milk chocolate, all kissed with almonds
  • Double Crossed Toffee — Fresh creamery butter, pure cane sugar, sweet almonds, smooth Madagascar vanilla, decadent milk and dark chocolate all criss-crossed with white chocolate
  • Nutty Twist Toffee — Doubly nutty, with a wicked twist of lime and tequila. Fresh macadamia nuts, tequila, tangy lime, creamy white chocolate, all teased with pure dark chocolate.
  • Lemon Berry Bliss Belgian Chocolate — What goes better with summer heat than the refreshing tang of blackberry lemonade? A layer of blackberry white chocolate topped with a layer of lemon white chocolate with blackberry swirls. I can feel that summer breeze already!

July Goody Box

  • Traditional Toffee — Rich, buttery goodness with Madagascar Bourbon vanilla, 72% dark cacao and Belgian milk chocolate, all kissed with almonds
  • Double Crossed Toffee — Fresh creamery butter, pure cane sugar, sweet almonds, smooth Madagascar vanilla, decadent milk and dark chocolate all criss-crossed with white chocolate
  • Sweet Heat² Toffee — One part sweet. Two parts heat. We start with pure cane sugar, almonds, Madagascar vanilla, Belgian dark and milk chocolates. Then, we kick it up not one, but Two notches by adding hatch green chile powder and cayenne pepper all topped with salted sunflower seeds.
  • Churro Toffee — Pure cane sugar, fresh creamery butter, Madagascar vanilla, and ground cinnamon coated in velvety white chocolate and sprinkled with a "Double" dose of cinnamon sugar.

August Goody Box

  • White Traditional Toffee — Made with fresh creamery butter, pure cane sugar and Madagascar vanilla, then smothered with creamy Belgian white chocolate, and smooched with almonds
  • Sweet & Salty Toffee — Sweet fresh almonds, Madagascar Bourbon vanilla and 72% dark Belgian cacao chocolate, all smooched with French coarse sea salt
  • Peanut Butter Cup Toffee — Delicious peanuts, creamery butter, pure cane sugar and Madagascar vanilla coated in rich peanut butter white chocolate and drizzled with milk chocolate swirls.
  • The Elvis Toffee — For the love of rock & roll! Pure cane sugar, creamery butter, and fresh peanuts covered with layers of 72% dark chocolate and topped with crushed banana chips. Thank you, thank you very much!

September Goody Box

  • Traditional Toffee — Rich, buttery goodness with Madagascar Bourbon vanilla, 72% dark cacao and Belgian milk chocolate, all kissed with almonds
  • White Traditional Toffee — Made with fresh creamery butter, pure cane sugar and Madagascar vanilla, then smothered with creamy Belgian white chocolate, and smooched with almonds
  • Cinnfully Hazelicious Toffee — Being a Goody-Goody is hard with something this Cinnfull! Fresh hazelnuts, ground cinnamon, and hazelnut liqueur covered in creamy milk chocolate and smooched with hazelnuts.
  • S’mores Toffee — Graham crackers, check! Mini marshmallows, check! Finally, chocolate, Double check! Toffee mixed with marshmallows and graham crackers, then smothered in Belgian milk chocolate, swirls of creamy white chocolate, and sprinkled with crushed graham crackers. Campfire, here we come!

October Goody Box

  • Traditional Toffee — Rich, buttery goodness with Madagascar Bourbon vanilla, 72% dark cacao and Belgian milk chocolate, all kissed with almonds
  • Double Crossed Toffee — Made with fresh creamery butter, pure cane sugar, sweet almonds, smooth Madagascar vanilla, decadent milk and dark chocolate all criss-crossed with white chocolate
  • Nutty Orange Toffee — Fresh chopped walnuts, pure cane sugar, creamery butter and Madagascar vanilla all coated in Belgian dark cacao infused with orange. Citrusly, it’s the zest!
  • Pumpkin Spice Toffee — You know it… You love it… PUMPKIN SPICE is now in toffee! 100% real pumpkin, all those feel-good spices, and freshly chopped pecans. Layer it all up with pumpkin white chocolate, chopped pecans, and cinnamon sugar. Autumn spice and "Double" the nice!

November Goody Box

  • Traditional Toffee — Rich, buttery goodness with Madagascar Bourbon vanilla, 72% dark cacao and Belgian milk chocolate, all kissed with almonds
  • Sweet & Salty Toffee — Sweet fresh almonds, Madagascar Bourbon vanilla and 72% dark Belgian cacao chocolate, all smooched with French coarse sea salt
  • 2-zel Crunch Toffee — The original Double Addiction, now in a square! Our traditional almond toffee topped with kettle corn and pretzels, then swirled with Belgian milk and white chocolate, and smooched with almonds.
  • Ginger Bourbon Toffee — Pure cane sugar, fresh creamery butter, chopped hazelnuts, ground ginger, and smooth bourbon topped with 72% dark cacao and swirled with milk chocolate.

December Goody Box

  • Traditional Toffee — Rich, buttery goodness with Madagascar Bourbon vanilla, 72% dark cacao and Belgian milk chocolate, all kissed with almonds
  • Double Crossed Toffee — Made with fresh creamery butter, pure cane sugar, sweet almonds, smooth Madagascar vanilla, decadent milk and dark chocolate all criss-crossed with white chocolate
  • Comfort & Joy Belgian Chocolate — A treasure of minty goodness with 72% cacao Belgian dark chocolate and creamy white chocolate layered with peppermint candy crunch. This seasonal favorite is just waiting to be unwrapped.
  • Black Forrest Toffee — Life is like a box of…toffee!? Fresh creamery butter, pure cane sugar, Madagascar vanilla, chopped almonds and cherries all coated in Belgian dark chocolate with white chocolate swirls and mini cherry chips. This toffee will make you want to RUN for more!

FAQs

What is included in the subscription box?

Each subscription box contains 8 individually wrapped squares of Goody-licious toffee. Flavors vary by month.

How much does it cost?

Subscription boxes are $49.95 per month. Subscriptions are automatically renewed unless you opt-out.

How often do I receive the boxes?

You will receive one box at the beginning of each month. Shipping times vary.

How much does shipping cost?

Toffee of the Month Club members receive FREE SHIPPING on subscription boxes!